
By: Jeff McGovern
Jeff is the lead financial planner at Haven Wealth Planning and has more than 16 years of experience in the wealth management industry. He has completed the Boston University Financial Planning Program and holds an MBA from Washington University in St. Louis. He received a Bachelor of Business Administration in finance and a Bachelor of Arts in markets and culture from Southern Methodist University in Dallas, Texas.
If you’ve ever wondered whether the effort of managing a health FSA is worth it, you’re not alone. Many families discover that a few thoughtful planning decisions can create meaningful tax savings on expenses they’re already paying. With practical examples and relatable scenarios, this guide shows how everyday households use a health FSA to build more control and confidence into their health spending. By the end, you’ll be equipped with clear next steps to apply to your own situation.
Learning Points
A Decision Framework
You can break down your decision on whether to participate and how much to contribute to a health FSA into three separate questions:
Should you participate at all? If your family has predictable medical expenses of any meaningful amount, then yes. The tax savings are meaningful and spread throughout the year’s payroll cycles.
The next threshold question is whether you can forecast your FSA eligible expenses reliably enough to avoid significant forfeiture.
How much should you elect? This is central planning question for most families when evaluating a health FSA. Generally, elect to contribute what you are confident that you’ll spend. Start by inventorying known recurring or regular expenses; prescriptions, co-pays, contact lens, glasses, and orthodontia. Do you anticipate any new high-dollar expenses like a planned procedure?
Then, factor in your plan’s carryover maximum or grace period feature. In 2026, you can carry over $680 into 2027. Electing the maximum contribution amount could put too much of your contributions at risk of forfeiture. The “optimal” health FSA election is the amount you’ll spend with near certainty.
FSA vs. HSA? For households on a high-deductible health plan, a Health Savings Account (HSA) provides a long-term savings vehicle with distinct advantages. The health FSA functions as a “spend this year” account. If your employer offers only an FSA – a common enough scenario – there’s no tradeoff to make.
Potential Tax Savings
A thoughtful health FSA strategy enables you to allocate pre-tax dollars toward healthcare costs you’d otherwise pay for with your after-tax income. Let’s walk through the three common payroll taxes you avoid when you contribute to your health FSA:
Federal Income Tax. Your health FSA Contributions reduce your W-2 taxable income dollar-for-dollar. For a couple in the 24% federal income tax bracket contributing the individual maximum of $3,400, that’s $816 in annual federal tax savings.
FICA. Unlike your 401(k), your health FSA contributions avoid Social Security (6.20%) and Medicare (1.45%) payroll taxes. A combined 7.65% that most people overlook.
State Income Tax. In most states, health FSA contributions are also exempt from state income tax. If you’re in the top bracket in Missouri, 4.70% is a meaningful tax savings.
Combined effective savings: A Missouri couple in the 24% federal bracket, 4.70% state bracket, and 7.65% FICA can expect to save roughly 36 cents on every dollar they contribute to their health FSA when they spend it on eligible expenses. If this couple contributed and spent the health FSA maximum of $3,400 in 2026, that’s ~$1,236 in taxes potentially saved on eligible medical expenses.
Health FSA Case Studies: Is a health FSA worth it?
Marcus and Sophia
The Dual-Income Family Running on Autopilot

The Household: Marcus and Sophia, both 38. Marcus is an operations manager at a specialty manufacturing firm. Sophia is an assistant principal at a suburban K-8 school. Together they have a combined income of $225,000. Two kids, ages 7 and 11. Both employers offer FSAs. The family is covered under Marcus’ PPO.
The Problem: They’d been enrolled in Marcus’ health FSA for three years and had been electing $1,000 each year because it “felt safe.” They never came close to forfeiting anything, which felt like a win. What they didn’t realize was that playing it safe, and repeating the previous year’s strategy was costing them money.
What They Found: A quick review of twelve months of EOBs and credit card records exported to Excel told a different story than $1,000 estimate. Their actual eligible medical expenses were just over $3,750; pediatric copays, Sophia’s thyroid prescription, phase-one braces for their 11-year-old, back-to-school eye exams, and a year’s worth of OTC medications that were unaccounted for. They anticipated that these expenses would continue in the upcoming year.
The Strategy: During their next open enrollment, Marcus elected a $3,400 annual contribution for his health FSA. Sophia opened her own health FSA through the school district and elected a $500 annual contribution. Together their annual health FSA contributions totaled $3,900. Marcus’ health FSA also has a carryover feature of up to $680, which provided them with the mental safety they value. Meaning of their $3,900 total contributions, they only needed to spend $3,220. They would spend the funds in Sophia’s health FSA first, and then Marcus’.
The Math: At their combined effective rate 22% federal, 4.70% Missouri state, 7.65% FICA, they can potentially save roughly 34 cents on every FSA dollar. On $3,900 of eligible medical expenses, that’s ~$1,340 in potential annual tax savings. Money they were already spending on their medical needs, just now working more efficiently for their family.
The Lesson: As your family grows, so, too, can your medical costs. A careful annual review can transform anxiety into an informed, reliable, repeatable savings strategy.
Matt and Bridget
The High-Income Household with a Planned Procedure

The Household: Matt and Bridget, both 49. Matt is a loan officer at a regional bank. Bridget was in corporate management role three years ago and now consults part-time. Combined income of $310,000. Their two teenagers are largely past the pediatric and orthodontia years. Healthcare costs were relatively quiet. Until they weren’t.
The Problem: Bridget has been advised by her medical team to undergo a planned gallbladder removal. Matt has a meniscus tear in his knee that needs scoping. Neither was urgent, but both were real. They’d been casually earmarking money for these procedures without connecting them to any tax planning.
What They Found: Bridget’s surgery was quoted at $4,000 out-of-pocket by a well-regarded practice in town. Matt’s arthroscopic knee procedure would cost roughly $2,500 in out-of-pocket costs after insurance. Both these planned costs are FSA-eligible. Both were schedulable on their timeline. Their realization was simple: this is $6,500 in planned, elective medical spending. There was no reason to pay for it with after-tax dollars.
The Strategy: Matt elected the $3,400 maximum on his health FSA. Bridget, as a part-time self-employed consultant, isn’t eligible for an FSA through her own work. Matt’s FSA can reimburse her expenses since she is his legal spouse. Bridget scheduled her surgery for late January to take advantage of the front-loading rule, with the full $3,400 available January 1. Her procedure was fully reimbursed shortly after they submitted the proper reimbursement documentation. Matt’s payroll deductions continued ratably through December. Given Matt’s schedule and desire to keep active, he was then able to schedule his knee scope for January of the following year.
The Math: At their marginal rate, 24% federal, 4.70% Missouri state, 7.65% Medicare, the effective savings rate on their health FSA contributions is approximately 36 cents on the dollar. On $3,400, that’s roughly $1,418 in tax savings on a necessary procedure. Paid with a tax-efficient approach using an employer benefit.
The Lesson: For higher-income households, a health FSA’s value scales meaningfully with marginal tax rates. Pairing it with planned elective procedures turns predictable healthcare spending into a thoughtful tax event.
Derek and Alicia
The Young Couple Planning to Start a Family

The Household: Derek and Alicia, both 28. Derek is a civil engineer at a mid-size infrastructure firm in the metro area. Alicia is a senior account manager at a regional marketing agency. Combined income of $180,000. Married three years. No kids yet but they plan to start a family soon.
The Problem: They viewed their health FSA as something to “figure out later”, not a financial tool connected to their day-to-day life. Neither had chronic conditions. Neither wore glasses or contacts. They were healthy and, accordingly, felt like health FSA participants with nothing to spend.
What They Found: The “healthy couple with nothing to spend” framing collapsed quickly when in the early fall they walked through what a pregnancy would cost, even with their good insurance. OB copays across three trimesters, hospital delivery deductible, prenatal vitamins (FSA-eligible), and pediatric newborn visits in the first months of life. Even on a strong employer plan, their first pregnancy would have between $2,500–$3,000 in out-of-pocket costs in the delivery year alone.
The Strategy: They conservatively elected to contribute $500 to Alicia’s health FSA since it allowed carryovers up to $680. More importantly, they developed a plan. After the birth of their first child, they would request to change their health FSA election during the plan year. They would then elect an amount that could better cover their anticipated health expenses.
The Math: They anticipate that by electing to contribute $2,500 to their health FSA at their effective rate, assuming 22.00% federal, 4.70% Missouri state, and 7.65% FICA, they could potentially save approximately $858 in taxes.
The Lesson: Your health FSA election can be fine-tuned to your family’s personal situation. Young couples who can estimate and plan before major life expenses happen are better positioned to maximize the value of their health FSA, precisely when costs spike. At delivery, in the pediatric years….and through the orthodontic years that follow.
Health FSA Frequently Asked Questions
Funding and Contributions
What do I contribute to my health FSA?
You contribute to your employer’s health FSA with your pre-tax payroll deductions.
How much can I contribute to my health FSA in 2026?
The maximum you can contribute to your health FSA for tax year 2026 is $3,400[i].
Can both my spouse and I open and fund a Health FSA?
Yes, if you each have an employer that offers a Health FSA, then you can each contribute to an account.
In 2026, this approach would allow a married couple to make up to $6,800 in health FSA contributions. That’s $3,400 contributed to each account. There are currently no joint health FSAs, only individual accounts.
Keep in mind that both spouses cannot seek reimbursement for the exact same qualified medical expenses.
Coordinate strategically. If you don’t anticipate spending more than current $3,400 health FSA maximum, opening a second FSA might not be the right approach.
Consider which employer offers better terms, carryover or grace period, easier to navigate digital experience, or a debit card for easier reimbursement. If one employer contributes a “seed” amount to your health FSA, maximize your benefits when it supports your financial goals.
What is the difference between a health FSA and an HSA?
For households on a high-deductible health plan, a Health Savings Account (HSA) provides a long-term savings vehicle with distinct advantages. The health FSA functions as a “spend this year” account.
Can we have both a health FSA and an HSA at the same time?
No. The above approach assumes that neither you nor your spouse plans to contribute to your Health Savings Account (HSA) in 2026.
Here’s why it matters. An HSA requires you to be enrolled in a High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP) and have no other “disqualifying coverage.” A health FSA counts as “disqualifying coverage”. A limited purpose FSA sidesteps this problem entirely. Because it only covers dental and vision, it does not interfere with your HSA eligibility.
For families with two working parents, where one spouse has an HSA and the other has access to an employer FSA, evaluate funding a Limited Purpose FSA through the FSA spouses plan. A limited purpose FSA can reimburse dental and vision expenses for the whole family. While the HSA spouse preserves their eligibility to contribute to and invest in their HSA.
If your family is navigating this scenario, verify with your plan administrator that a Limited Purpose FSA is available through your employer’s cafeteria plan.
What is a Limited Purpose FSA?
A Limited Purpose FSA is a variation of the standard Health FSA that restricts eligible expenses to dental and vision care only. It is specifically designed for households where one spouse participates in a Health Savings Account (HSA).
Can I get a health FSA if I’m self-employed?
No. Health FSAs are only available through employer-sponsored plans. Self-employed individuals should instead look at HSAs (if on an HDHP), HRAs (if offered), or directly deducting health premiums.
Mid-Year Changes
Can I change my health FSA contribution election mid-year?
Yes, but these are relatively more restricted than during open enrollment. Outside of a specifically defined change of status events, your health FSA benefit election is locked for the plan year. This makes upfront planning essential.
If you’re curious whether you could make a mid-year change, verify whether your specific election change clears these hurdles and confirm with your plan’s administrator:
Employer’s Plan Design. Verify which qualifying life events your employer’s plan permits changing your election during a period of coverage. For context Section 125 does not require your employer’s cafeteria plan to permit mid-year changes. It defines which qualifying life events are permissible.
Consistency Rule. Confirm whether your health FSA election change request logically ties to a change of status. A qualifying life event does not grant an open-ended right to change your health FSA election. You’ll want to verify if the election change is on account of and corresponds with a change in status that affects eligibility for coverage under the employer’s plan.
Timing. Health FSAelection changesneed to be requested within the plan’s election change window. Typically, this window is within 30 or 60 days of the change of status event.
Election Changes are Prospective. If you change your health FSA election mid-year, the changes will be effective in the future. You plan will confirm the start date for your new election.
Health FSA: Change of Status
The table below shows which life events qualify as a permitted change of status for a Health FSA election.
| Life Event | Health FSA Change of Status? | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Change in legal marital status; marriage, death of spouse, legal separation, and annulment. | Yes | §1.125-4(c)(2)(i) |
| Change in number of dependents; birth, death, adoption, or placement of adoption. | Yes | §1.125-4(c)(2)(ii) |
| Change in employment status | Yes | §1.125-4(c)(2)(iii) |
| Dependent gains or loses eligibility | Yes | §1.125-4(c)(2)(iv) |
| Change in residence | No | §1.125-4(c)(2)(v) |
| Judgement, decree, or order / qualified medical child support order from divorce or legal separation | Yes | §1.125-4(d) |
| Entitlement to, or loss of, Medicare or Medicaid | Yes | §1.125-4(e) |
| Cost or coverage changes (premium changes, new plan options, etc.) | Explicitly Excluded | §1.125-4(f) |
Source: Treas. Reg. §1.125-4 Permitted election changesi.
i 26 CFR 1.125-4. ECFR.gov, Accessed March 4, 2026. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-26/chapter-I/subchapter-A/part-1/subject-group-ECFRb467872627553f1/section-1.125-4
What happens to my health FSA funds if I go on FMLA /parental leave?
It depends on whether your leave is paid or unpaid, and how your employer’s plan handles it. Confirm with your HR or benefits administrator before your leave begins. Before that conversation, here is the general framework:
Paid Leave. Your health FSA contributions typically continue through regular payroll deductions. Your full elected balance remains available, and you can continue submitting reimbursement claims as usual.
Unpaid Leave. Your employer’s plan may offer two options. You can either pre-pay your remaining health FSA contributions before your leave begins, or you can catch up with contributions when you return. Some plans suspend your account during unpaid leave and reinstate it upon your return.
One thing that does not change: your ability to be reimbursed for eligible expenses incurred before or during your leave is protected by FMLA. Your employer cannot terminate your FSA participation solely because you are on FMLA leave.
A few practical, tactical approaches to consider for families planning ahead to FMLA leave:
If you are expecting a baby, a birth qualifies as a change of status event. You can request to increase your FSA election mid-year after delivery to cover your newborn’s qualified medical expenses.
Front-load your reimbursement claims before leave if your plan will suspend contributions during unpaid leave. The front-loading means your full elected balance is available on January 1, regardless of what you’ve contributed so far.
Coordinate with your spouse’s FSA or HSA if applicable. Their account may be able to cover expenses while your account is suspended.
Does my full, annual FSA election amount become available immediately?
Yes, on day one of your plan year, your entire elected annual amount is available for use. Even if you haven’t contributed all of it yet via payroll deductions.
For example, if you elect to contribute $3,400 to your health FSA and have a $4,000 dental procedure in January, you can submit $3,400 for full reimbursement immediately. Then, you can effectively pay it back through payroll deductions over the remainder of the plan year.
This health FSA feature, sometimes called front-loading, distinguishes it from virtually every other tax-advantaged account.
By contrast, an HSA and 401(k) require you make contribution before spending or withdrawing funds from either account. If you’re someone who enjoys finding the little edges in life, and it’s worth front loading planned eligible medical expenses earlier in the year.
If you leave your job mid-year after spending the full balance but only contributing a portion, your employer generally cannot recover the difference.
Eligible Items and Expenses
What can I use my health FSA funds to pay for?
After you contribute to your health flexible spending account, you can use these funds to pay for qualified medical expenses that are not covered by your current health plan, such as; co-pays, deductibles, medical products, services ranging from dental and vision care, eyeglasses and hearing aids.
What common family expenses are FSA-eligible that people don’t realize?
Many couples are surprised by the breadth of eligible items. Beyond copays and prescriptions, FSA funds can be used for: sunscreen (SPF 15+), menstrual products, breast pumps and lactation supplies, acupuncture, chiropractic care, fertility treatments (including IVF), mental health therapy, over-the-counter medications, and even a portion of long-term care costs.
A comprehensive health FSA eligibility list from your plan administrator is worth reviewing annually.
Can FSA funds be used for our children’s expenses?
Yes. Your health FSA can reimburse your spouse’s eligible medical expenses regardless of whether they are on your health plan, if they are your legal spouse and you file taxes accordingly. This is one of the most underutilized benefits for dual-income couples.
Carryover and Grace Period Features
What happens if I don’t spend all my health FSA contributions in 2026?
Your employer may offer one of the following two options:
Carryover: In 2026, you may carry over up to $680 into 2027.
Grace Period: Your employer could allow you an additional two months and fifteen days after the 2026 plan year ends to spend remaining funds. This time frame is commonly reframed as 2.5 months.
Keep in mind that some employers offer neither of these options. This approach is frequently described as “use it or lose it”. Meaning, there is no flexibility to spend unused health FSA contributions after the year ends.
If both my spouse and I have a health FSA, can we use one account’s carryover funds to cover the other’s expenses?
Yes, you can use these carryover funds for health FSA qualified expenses incurred by you, your spouse and dependents. Your health FSA accounts remain separate, but eligible expenses are shared.
Forfeiture
Who keeps the forfeited contributions?
The forfeited health FSA funds go back to the employer. Employers may use these forfeited funds to offset plan administrative costs or redistribute them to all plan participants.
This makes the case for careful annual planning — you’re effectively leaving pre-tax dollars on the table for your employer if you forfeit. The tax savings on FSA contributions (typically 25–35% of contributed dollars for a middle-income couple) makes accurate election planning one of the highest-ROI tax moves available.
I anticipate taking a role with a new employer / leaving my job this year. Should I contribute to my health FSA?
Health FSAs are employer accounts and are not portable, whether you find yourself unemployed or changing employers. This means your health FSA contributions could potentially be lost/forfeited if you lose your job or leave your current company. If either you, or your spouse, sense that your current employment situation is in transition, consider this:
If you’ve already elected to fund your account, don’t wait to seek reimbursement for qualified medical expenses.
During your next open enrollment period, evaluate how much you want to contribute to your FSA and consider a more conservative contribution amount. Alternatively, if your anticipated qualified medical expenses are below the annual health FSA contribution amount, your spouse could contribute to their employer’s health FSA.
Reimbursement
How do I get reimbursed from my health FSA?
Most health FSA administrators offer two reimbursement paths; an FSA debit card for point-of-sale purchases and a manual claim submission for expenses you’ve already paid out of pocket.
Using your health FSA debit card. Many employers issue a debit card that’s linked directly to your health FSA. You can use it at a pharmacy, at your doctor’s office, or at a retailer for eligible OTC items. Even when you use the card, your plan administrator may still request documentation afterward to verify the expense was eligible. Keep your receipts and Explanations of Benefits (EOBs).
Submitting a manual reimbursement claim. If you paid for health FSA-eligible expenses out of pocket, log into your FSA administrator’s online portal or app and submit a claim. You will need to provide documentation that establishes three things: the date of service, the nature of the service or item, and the amount charged.
An EOB from your insurer, an itemized receipt from a pharmacy, or an itemized bill from a hospital or clinic are good starting points. Reimbursement timelines vary by administrator, but most process claims within three to five business days once documentation is approved.
A few things worth knowing:
1. You can submit claims for expenses incurred at any point during the plan year, up to your plan’s filing deadline. For some plans, this is 90 days after the plan year ends (i.e. March 31).
2. If your FSA debit card is declined, it usually means the merchant’s category code isn’t recognized as FSA-eligible. That is not to say the item itself is ineligible. If this happens, you can choose to pay out of pocket and submit a manual reimbursement claim.
3. Save your documentation. Your employer or FSA administrator can audit claims and request substantiation at any time.
What documentation do I need to substantiate an FSA reimbursement claim?
Each FSA reimbursement you submit will need to be substantiated by third-party documentation that establishes three things, i) the date of service, ii) the nature of the service or item, and iii) the amount charged.
In practice, this means an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) from your insurer, an itemized receipt from a pharmacy or provider, or an itemized bill from a hospital or clinic. A credit card statement alone does not meet the standard, because it doesn’t establish the nature of the service.
The Next Step
We help busy parents and professionals like you develop financial plans to address questions like:
- How can we save for a fulfilling retirement beyond our 401(k) plans?
- What does it take to save for the kids’ education and make a lifetime of memories along the way?
- These causes are close to our hearts. What are our options to give even more meaningful support?
As your financial planner in St. Louis, we can help you get organized and start feeling more confident that you are making progress towards your savings priorities.
Working with your financial planner in St. Louis can provide you with the right mix of accountability, collaboration, and long-term thinking.
When you know who and what are truly important, we can help you create incredible clarity about your spending and savings priorities. Clarity to confidently save for and spend on what matters.
If you’re ready to take the next step and work with a financial planner in St. Louis, let’s talk.
Disclosure
This commentary is provided for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax, or legal advice. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice. Investors are advised to consult with their investment professional about their specific financial needs and goals before making any investment decision.
[i] IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32, “Administrative, Procedural, and Miscellaneous”, IRS.gov, Internal Revenue Service, Accessed: March 3, 2026, https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf